Latin
America's banking sector saw a flurry of M&A deals last year, led
by international banks looking to boost their presence in fast-growing
emerging markets.
Those deals easily grab headlines due to the big
numbers and the
parties involved cannot stop repeating how beneficial the new merger
will be in terms of cost savings and synergies. However, many times
those deals deliver less than they initially promised for a number of
reasons and one of those is the cultural dilemma of cross-border
deal-making.
To find out more about what cross-cultural
problems the buyers
from last year may encounter this year, BNamericas spoke to
best-selling author and cross-cultural consultant Terri Morrison.
Morrison is president of consulting firm Getting
Through Customs
and co-author of the book Kiss, Bow or Shake Hands, which won an award
for best business book in 2007 from Library Journal.
BNamericas:
How important are national cultures today when globalization is
marching at an ever faster pace and Thomas Friedman says the "world is
flat?"
Morrison: The world is getting flatter, as Thomas
Friedman says in his great book, but traditions dating back hundreds or
even thousands of years do not change that easily and they have to be
considered when doing business in foreign countries. In every culture
there is a range of variables that will determine your degree of
success in negotiations and managing people.
BNamericas:
Many international banks made big investments in M&As last year in
Latin America. What are the main things for these companies to keep in
mind to integrate successfully the banks they bought and to manage
their new employees?
Morrison: First you face the
challenge of the different corporate cultures, which in some companies
can be dogmatic. Then on top of that you have the different national
cultures to consider and to do that successfully it's always
fundamental to listen and appreciate the experience of the people on
the other side of the table. In cross-border mergers and acquisitions
it's vital to let people from the other country feel that they are part
of the process and it is also tremendously important to have an open
mind. To build trust from the start is crucial in these processes.
It's
also important that headquarters send executives who have both the
necessary technical and cross-cultural skills to lead the new teams
that will be formed.
BNamericas: Canada's Scotiabank has
been very aggressive in Latin America over the last few years, buying
several banks in different countries. How do you see the Canadian
executives faring in the cultural waters of Latin America?
Morrison:
Generally Canadians are open-minded, so that in itself should help
reduce the risk of cross-cultural conflicts. However, there are some
major cultural differences between Canadians and Latin Americans in
terms of how they view time and physical space. Punctuality could
become an issue if your new boss is British-Canadian; or if the
British-Canadian executives maintain a larger physical distance when in
meetings or at social events.
To take an extreme example,
some of the physical contact between male and female co-workers in
Brazil could easily be seen as sexual harassment in the US. On my first
trips to Brazil I was initially surprised by the close proximity and
felt uncomfortable. Then I realized that was normal and acceptable
behavior in Brazil, and I started to relax. Nowadays it's no longer a
problem at all!
BNamericas: What about South Africans? Standard
Bank from South Africa is also on the move in Latin America's banking
sector.
Morrison:
South Africans benefit from not having a cut-throat approach to
business. For them it is not about, I win and you lose. Instead they
take the win-win approach when doing business abroad and that helps to
overcome the cultural obstacles they may face in foreign markets.
BNamericas:
Last year the Chilean branch of Citigroup announced it was going to
merge with local bank Banco de Chile and in the beginning of this year
they started to operate as one. In general, what problems or challenges
do executives from the US face when working in Chile or other Latin
American countries?
Morrison: Business can be done at
lightning speed in the US in comparison to many Latin American
countries. Punctuality is highly emphasized and delays are seen as
insults. In order to save time, tremendous amounts of data are
transmitted through webexs and archived on corporate intranets rather
than discussed in person. US executives find the difference in pace and
general perceptions of time to be challenging in Latin America.
Executives
from the US also love the newest technical gadgets and many do not mind
using them during meetings. US managers "talking" on a Blackberry,
iphone, or the latest communications device while others are in the
room can be highly irritating to Latin American executives. For them
the cultural challenge is to realize that it is common practice in the
US and your US associate may assume that a call is as important as the
physical person in front of him or her.
In terms of
negotiations, short-term goals and rewards are the normal focus for US
managers while Latin American executives often consider the longer term
relationship to be a priority.
BNamericas: Despite having
a very strong global brand when buying Mexico's Banamex in 2001,
Citigroup decided to keep the local brand and has not changed it since.
Would you say that branding is a particularly difficult issue for banks
and other companies when buying local competitors?
Morrison:
It can be because in some regions of the world, like Latin America,
Africa and the Middle East, consumers tend to be very loyal to people
and brands. In these cultures, people look for stability and long-term
relationships. Whereas in the US we tend to be less loyal to brands and
always look for the newest and the best, wanting to have the "next
thing."
BNamericas: Any other factors playing against
implementing a global brand versus keeping a local brand after an
acquisition or merger?
Morrison: There is also the
language problem. There have been so many blunders in terms of
translating names in international business and also of famous
international brands that acquire a negative connotation in some
cultures. So sometimes it is better to simply stick with what works.
BNamericas:
Some experts say that Chile has the potential to become an offshore
location for international financial groups looking to outsource
certain service jobs. From your experience, what are some chief factors
for countries or cities that aspire to become attractive offshore
locations?
Morrison: Considering Chile's telecom
infrastructure, stable economy and politics I think there's a great
opportunity. However, it is a key factor that the people who will
perform those jobs are well prepared and therefore training becomes a
fundamental issue. Dell, for example, chose to outsource customer
service jobs to India and encountered some significant public relations
problems because local staff was not thoroughly prepared. Such problems
are serious because they can damage your company's credibility and
brand name.
BNamericas: Lastly, I would like to know what you
are working on right now? A new book maybe?
Morrison:
I am planning to start work on a series of books that combines the
cultural aspects of doing international business with linguistic
challenges. We will probably start with "Kiss, Bow or Shake Hands:
Doing Business in Spanish," and "Kiss, Bow or Shake Hands: Doing
Business in Mandarin."
About
Terri Morrison
Terri
Morrison holds a BS in education with a minor in Spanish, and a masters
in human resources. She has worked for Booze Allen & Hamilton and
in 1990 she started Getting Through Customs, a software, training and
research firm for international business travelers.
Besides
being president of Getting Through Customs, Morrison is the co-author
of five books, including the best-selling Kiss, Bow or Shake Hands: How
to Do Business in Sixty Countries. The latest edition of that book has
sold more then 250,000 copies.
She conducts seminars in
intercultural communications, and has written on cross-cultural
communications for many US and European publications, including
American Airlines' in-flight magazine American Way, Swissair's Gazette,
Sabena's PASSPORT, CEO Magazine, OAG's Frequent Flyer, and Industry
Week online.
Morrison has appeared on many media
broadcasts, including CNN, CNBC and NPR. She also serves on several
boards, including the International Academy at Santa Barbara.
ABOUT
THE COMPANY:
Getting
Through Customs publishes Kiss, Bow or Shake Hands: Expanded Edition,
an online reference of global business & social practices,
cognitive styles, export and travel information. Among the company's
clients are: Accenture, AT&T, Cisco Systems, Deloitte & Touche,
Dun & Bradstreet, Ernst & Young, Global Crossing, IBM, Lucent
Technologies, National Association of Realtors, Novartis, SABRE, and
universities like Cornell, Harvard, The Wharton School, Princeton and
Oxford.
By
Ulric Rindebro