|
Many executives dread their first business trip to a new country. It's
natural to feel off-balance in unfamiliar surroundings. You might not
understand the language or the customs. But some travelers add the additional
burden of incorrect or out-of-date expectations. They forget that a good story
isn't necessarily an accurate one.
Unfortunately, some tall tales die slowly. In 1940 an amateur linguist
misinterpreted some 1911 research of Eskimo languages. The linguist, Benjamin
Lee Whorf, claimed that while English has only one word for snow, Eskimo has
many, with separate words for falling snow, slushy snow, and so on.
Whorf's article contained two errors. First, English has several words for
snow, including powder, sleet, and slush. Second, comparing word-counts between
radically different languages has little meaning. The Inuits (the modern term
for Eskimo) use lots of prefixes and suffixes, combining several concepts into
a long, compound word English-speakers can say the same thing by using several
words instead of one long one. For example, in Inuktitut (an Inuit language),
the generic term for snow is "aput." In English we add an adjective
to describe the concept of "new snow." Inuktitut expresses the same
concept by adding suffixes to make the single word "aputiqarniq."
So Whorf's original article was misleading, to say the least. But the story
of the Inuits' many words for snow grew. Some report it as 50, or 100, or even
200 words. (What is the correct number? The linguists at Canada's Department of
Indian and Northern Affairs now report "over 30" variations of
Inuktitut words for snow, all of them based on just a few root words.)
Now, not many of us are conducting business deals with the Inuit. But we've
all heard misinformation about other cultures. We need to regard these
preconceived ideas with skepticism before traveling internationally.
Take another stereotype: You only do business with men in Muslim countries.
True, Muslim countries usually place more restrictions on the activities of
women than they do on men. But there are still women in positions of power in
Muslim countries. Pakistana predominantly Muslim countryhad a woman
prime minister, Benazir Bhutto. Turkey, which is officially secular but is
predominantly Muslim, has almost as many women executives as men. If you go to
many Muslim countries expecting never to see a woman in business, you may be
surprised.
Our foreign expectations come from many sources, including stereotypes,
ethnic jokes, and movies. Yet all of these can be wrong. We shouldn't expect
accurate portrayals from stereotypes or ethnic jokes. And Hollywood wants to
make profitable, entertaining shows; accuracy is never the primary
consideration.
But what about carefully documented research materials (such as the books
written by the authors of this column)? Yes, these are accurate. But no book
covers everything. Many countries are as diverse as the U.S. Would you expect a
resident of New York to act the same as residents of Helena, Montana? Or a
programmer in the Silicon Valley to act as an Amish person from the
Pennsylvania Dutch country? Of course not. And you can find regional
differences in many countries, not only in large countries such as India and
China but in small ones such as Belgium.
Furthermore, everyone is an individual. Are you a "typical"
American? You probably share many traits in common with your fellow citizens,
but differ in other ways. There are undoubtedly French citizens who hate wine,
Italians who don't gesture when talking, and Japanese who never apologize.
So, when you embark on that business trip overseas, try to leave behind any
preconceptions based on suspect sources such as jokes or movies. And, while
books and articles by experts are useful, don't expect every individual to act
in predictable ways.
Reprinted from IndustryWeek, March 24, 1998
|